Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Divine Intervention

   Divine intervention is something that has been questioned for years.It is argued that there is a higher power above us that controls and interferes with our own fate. Many people question this theory. Is divine intervention something that is real or do we, as people, ultimately have control over our own destiny's and lives? Do all of our actions lead up to what the outcome of our lives will be or is someone "upstairs" controlling this and stepping in when they feel is necessary? Recently, we have completed the first half of the Odyssey. In the book, Homer reveals a chain of events that occur while Odysseus is attempting to make his way back to Ithaca. We are told that it was the Gods that decide to allow Odysseus to return home, but along the way he was going to encounter a list of inevitable events that would make his journey home even more difficult. However, throughout the story we see examples of how Odysseus' decisions reflect his own fate. Homer provides us with both sides to the argument. We are given multiple examples of when the goddess, Athena, interferes with Odysseus' setbacks providing him with aid, advice, and "hints." We also see examples of the god, Poseidon, causing his ship to crash and his crew to drown. But on the other hand, Homer provides Odysseus control his own fate to some extent. A prime example of this would be when Odysseus visits the land of the dead. At the land of the dead, he encounters Tiresias, a legendary Theban prophet, who reveals to him his fate IF he chooses to slay the cattle of the Sun god. Another example would be when the nymph goddess, Circe, instructs Odysseus on what path he should take and what he should do while sailing at sea past the island of the Sirens, Scylla, and Charybdis. She does not choose the path for Odysseus, but leaves the decision up to him. This suggests that Homer believes in both sides. Maybe there is a such thing as divine intervention, but this so-called "higher power" gives us the freedom of what path we want to take. Thus resulting in the obstacles we face. Or maybe is the complete opposite, and the higher power already knows what path were going to take and "planned" it to be that way. No one really knows the answer.

3 comments:

  1. I know the answer.... our fate is predetermined for us. We just follow the path that the "higher power" gave us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like how you wrote this blog first poses the question of fate to the audience, and then explianing how greek's beliefs of fate is played out in the "Odyssey". I feel like this post is like an answer to one of the essay questions on our test yesterday. I personally believe are fate is predetermined, but it is something to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  3. An insightful look at 'The Odyssey' and Homer's ambiguity concerning divine intervention. This reflects the fact that the Greeks used myth to help them understand reality. If their myths were too "mythical" and not realistic enough, the stories wouldn't reflect life. Layering myth on top of reality helps the Greeks deal with tough questions like: 'Is life fair?' 'Does crime really pay?' 'Why do good people die young?'
    Tips for future posts:
    *Be sure to divide your ideas into paragraphs.
    *Avoid 'rambling' introductions that don't advance your thesis.
    Good stuff overall.

    ReplyDelete